“Where Are You?” (3:1-24)
Neal Pollard
A dramatic shift occurs as we come to chapter three. The beautiful ending of chapter two is that “the man and his wife were both naked and were not ashamed” (2:25). It is harder to find a purer picture of innocence and carefree life than the sinless condition of Adam and Eve as revealed at their creation.
Genesis 3 explains how things changed and what the consequences of that are, not only for the first couple but for all subsequent humanity. It is important to keep in mind that these events are presented in narrative style and are not myth or legend. Bible writers who look back on Adam speak of him as historical, not fictional (1 Chron. 1:1; Job 31:33; Hos. 6:7; Luke 3:38; Rom. 5:14; 1 Cor. 15:45; etc.). The same is true of Eve (2 Cor. 11:3; 1 Tim. 2:13). We will examine the serpent momentarily. Consider the content of this important, if grim, chapter.
The Serpent And Sin (1-7)
There are so many interpretations concerning the serpent. Reyburn and Fry say, “Serpent, which translates the usual word for ‘snake,’ has had a long history of interpretation. Some commentators have held that the serpent refers to Satan in disguise. Others have taken the position that it is a symbol for curiosity. The serpent is found in the stories of many societies as the creature who brings good luck, knowledge, and wealth, and who is sometimes described as being able to speak” (81). Yet, the serpent is introduced as a beast which God made (1). Connect that statement back to Genesis 2:19.
What does seem clear is that Satan is somehow involved in this incident. Satan is called “the serpent of old” (Rev. 12:9). He is the father of lies (John 8:44). Combining those facts with the curse of verse 15 leads us to conclude that Satan uses the apparently willing and crafty serpent to tempt Eve (2 Cor. 11:3,14).
The focus of the text is the temptation. The serpent “deceives” Eve (13). He does so by casting doubt on God’s command (1; 2:16-17), implying that God is unfair (1), denying truth (4), and suggesting that God is trying to prevent Adam and Eve from having better and more (5). By entertaining his arguments, Eve opens the door of her heart to temptation. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil appeals to her flesh, her eye, and her pride (6; 1 John 2:16). She eats and gives to Adam, who also eats (6). Their eyes are opened, but it does not have the anticipated effect. Instead, they are filled with shame (7).
James Smith writes, “These additional points in Satan’s temptation strategy should be noted: (1) he attacked when Eve was alone; (2) he selected the ground carefully, waiting until the woman was in full view of the tree; (3) he employed ambiguous and obscure language; and (4) he pretended to be seeking only the best for his victim” (The Pentateuch, 67). Oh that we could always remember that “sin’s seductive promises always turn out to be a mirage”
(Strassner, 35).
The Search (8-13)
The chapter opens with a dialogue between the serpent and the innocent woman. Next, we see the dialogue between God and the sinful couple. Eric Owens once reminded me that it is all too easily to read into this text what is not there. Do you ever imagine the tone of God’s voice and His response as severe and scolding? Look closely at this chapter and see if you see evidence of it!
Instead, Moses tells us the couple hears the sound of the Lord God walking in the garden… (8). What a comfort that must have been before this day! Now, hearing it, their instinct is to hide. Sin covets cover (8)! Their sin has led them to shame.
We read that God calls to the man and asks, “Where are you?” (9). Whatever else you deduce, do not miss that God pursues those who chose to disobey Him! He does not leave them to languish and suffer in their sin without His guidance and instruction. In God’s subsequent questions–“Who told you that you were naked” (11), “Have you eaten from the tree of which I commanded you not to eat?” (11), and (to the woman) “what is this you have done?” (13).
Of course, the God who is revealed in Scripture as all-knowing (Psa. 139; John 2:25; 1 John 3:20). These questions are not for His information, but for Adam and Eve’s instruction. They are rhetorical, yet beneficial for their spiritual recovery. Like the rest of God’s Word, these words are a mirror for their reflection. Adam, though deflecting (10,12), ultimately confesses (12). Eve, also redirecting, nonetheless confesses (13).
The Sentence (14-24)
The just God metes out punishment. He is full of integrity and must keep His word (Num. 23:19). God addresses the guilty.
The serpent will crawl on its belly and eat dust (14). There will be enmity between the seed of the serpent and the seed of woman (15), with the latter ultimately triumphing. Given the earlier discussion about the serpent and Satan, we must understand the import of this statement. From ancient interpreters on down, this has been called the “protoevangelium” (the first gospel proclamation). This is fostered by Paul’s words that “the God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet” (Rom. 16:20a) as well as the Messianic Genealogies that follow in chapters four and five. See also Hebrews 2:14-15. The idea is that the devil would experience triumph in the death of the Messiah, but the Messiah would deal a greater, crushing blow through His resurrection.
The woman will experience pain in childbirth and her husband would rule over her (16). The middle phrase, “your desire will be for your husband,” appears to be less about the sexual and more about her role. Kenneth Matthews points to Genesis 4:7 as a parallel to this verse, saying, “The ‘desire’ of the woman is her attempt to control her husband, but she will fail because God has ordained that the man exercise his leadership function. The force of the defeat is obscured somewhat by the rendering ‘and he will rule’; the conjunction is better understood as ‘but he will rule'” (NAC, 251). This is cemented in 1 Corinthians 11:3. No doubt, the woman in her rebellion has the most painful consequence.
The man will suffer a cursed ground as he attempts to cultivate it (17). He will contend with thorns and thistles (18) and will grow food only with difficulty and adversity (19). Not only that, but he will die–return to the ground and go back to the dust he came from (19). This is not to suggest that all men, subsequently, would be farmers. It is to say that his heretofore pleasant and unobstructed work will no longer be either of these things.
All three, serpent, woman, and man, receive a punishment that fits their sin. In fact, in two of the three pronouncements, the punishment was given “because” (14, 17). Likewise, the woman who led her husband into sin was now to be led by him.
After a couple of notes of explanation–Adam naming his wife, now endowed with childbearing, “Eve” (mother of all living) and God compassionately clothing the couple reeling from the shame of knowing their nakedness (20-21)–there is one last part to their sentencing. They must leave their garden paradise (22-24). They must be separated from the tree of life (22), and cherubim would guard the tree of life with a flaming sword (24). We do not see these created beings referenced in this duty station anywhere later in Scripture, and their appearance would no doubt have been frighteningly intimidating. Surely, neither Adam nor his descendants dared get close to this spot again.
As Milton famously dubbed it, this describes “paradise lost.” The New Testament sheds further light on the spiritual implication of these events. Indeed, “…through one man sin entered into the world, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men, because all sinned” (Rom. 5:12). That context shows the cost of “the offense of Adam” (Rom. 5:14), the deadly transgression (Rom. 5:15-18), and the resulting condemnation (Rom. 5:16,18). But thank God for His grace that brings life, justification, and righteousness where it is not deserved (Rom. 5:16-19). God knew man would eventually exercise his free will to sin, and He already had the rescuing response ready! Even in the frightful darkness, God exerts His life-giving remedy.
The Preacher Pollard Blog 