A Calloused Resentment (4:1-11)
Neal Pollard
When called to preach to Gentiles, Jonah panicked. When swallowed by the fish, Jonah prayed. When spit up from the fish, Jonah preached. When God spared Nineveh, Jonah pouted. Our introduction to the prophet is unfavorable, but our last glimpse of him is even worse. It pleased God to save believers through preaching (1 Cor. 1:21), but God’s choice to save these believers displeased the preacher! Unfathomable, but undeniable.
Audaciously, Jonah is angry with God! His prayer is a protest. He begs to know why God would put him to such trouble, calling him from his own country when he was going to do this to a notoriously wicked people. While he appeals to the oft-quoted passage concerning God’s character and nature, first spoken by the Lord to Moses in Exodus 34:6 and repeated throughout the Old Testament, it is in neither praise or thanksgiving. It is more accurately a complaint (2). He does not want God to relent and spare the Assyrians.
Why would Jonah react this way? I like the concise of explanation of Smith and Page: “At the very worst we see a prophet with a shocking disregard for human life and a bitter hatred toward those who had experienced mercy. At the very best he was a prophet who misunderstood God’s mercy and had a limited view of God’s plan for the redemption of his own people. While there may have been some reasons for Jonah’s displeasure, it is sad to see him place limits on the same grace that saved him” (NAC, 272).
Notice how different the contents of this prayer are from the prayer he prayed concerning himself in chapter two. He had benefited from the grace of God personally, but he begrudged others enjoying it. He is so unwilling to accept God’s decision that he pouts and asks that his life be taken from him (3). He’d rather die than see the Assyrians live. But as God had compassionately appealed to the hearts of the people of Nineveh, He appeals to the heart of Jonah. It is remarkably like the parable of the Prodigal Son, with Jonah reminding us of the elder brother.
Isn’t the main point the question Jonah asks twice? “Do you have good reason to be angry?” (4,9). Apparently, between hearing that question a first and second time, Jonah has prepared his reply. Bitterly, when asked again, Jonah says, “I have a good reason to be angry, to the point of death” (9b). In between these questions, Jonah left the city to sit in the apparently sweltering heat to await the fate of the city (still hoping he’d see God destroy it?)(5). God enhances Jonah’s makeshift shade with a miraculously rapid growing plant that brings him great comfort (6). The next day, God appoints a worm to wither the plant and He appoints a scorching east wind along with a baking sun that brought Jonah to the point of despair and desiring death (7-8). God wants to know if Jonah had a right to be angry about the plant, and Jonah emphatically confirms that he did (9).
God brings home the point of this dramatic object lesson to try and reach the prophet’s heart one last time. Jonah didn’t create, plant, or grow the plant. It “came up overnight and perished overnight” (10). Yet, it bothered him to see the plant die because of how it affected him. God wishes Jonah to understand that these 120,000 men, women, and children have eternal souls, are made in His image, and were destined to spend eternity somewhere. He wanted them saved (Ezek. 18:23; 1 Tim. 2:4; 2 Pet. 3:9)!
Maybe it is hard to see ourselves in Jonah. We are baffled at Jonah’s prejudice and see clearly God’s point of view. But how often do we want for our sinful selves what we do not want for others whose sinfulness may be viewed as greater than ours in some way? Do we have less patience for their sin struggles than we want God to have for our own? Do we ever rebel against the mission God gives us, choosing our own way over His? Are we ever unhappy with following God’s plan, especially when we do not understand it? This is not a Jewish problem. This is a human problem. Christians are not exempt from a Jonah-like spirit. Even when it is difficult, we must openly share God’s gracious invitation to “whosoever will” (Rev. 22:17)! That is our mission (Matt. 28:18-20).
