The Deadly Contagion Called Complaining (12:1-16)
Neal Pollard
Almost always, in the book of Numbers, the complaining comes from among the rank and file of the nation. In Numbers 12, we see this spirit infesting even the leadership. God’s appointed leader, Moses, depended much on his siblings, Aaron and Miriam, for the day to day operation of guiding the people toward Canaan. Here, we see their critical spirit and God’s response. We also learn some important insight into how such matters arise.
There was an underlying cause for the complaint (1). It is not clear from context if they were envious of Moses’ position or power, but they seem to feel equally entitled to recognition and authority. This is a feeling that God would verbally dispute (6-8). Neither is it clear why Moses’ wife’s origin, a Cushite, fueled their contempt. But it did! Likely this Cushite was Zipporah, the wife Moses took in Midian (cf. Hab. 3:7). Commentators logically surmise that especially Miriam would feel threatened by the rival influence of Moses’ wife would diminish her own influence as a woman in his life. This is certain. Often the real reason and motive for the complaint is not what is stated, but is instead some ulterior issue. Therefore, the heart is where such issues need to be addressed. If this does not happen, the consequences can be severe.
The Lord hears our complaints against his appointed leaders (2). Aaron and Miriam spoke against Moses “and the Lord heard it.” This phrase ought to sober us all. Such criticism is often petty and we fail to remember that God is omnipresent. He hears what we say, and He knows why we say it.
The Lord defends His leaders (3-9). Moses is established as a humble man back in chapter 11 regarding Eldad and Medad (11:29). Thus, in his meekness, Moses does not defend himself (3). However, God’s response is sudden (4)! It is emphatic. He summons all three of them to entrance of the tabernacle (4-5). He lets them know that their criticism of Moses was actually leveled at Him. Not only did God call Moses to lead the people (Ex. 3-4), but He maintained an intimate relationship with Moses, telling them, “With him I speak mouth to mouth, clearly, and not in riddles, and he beholds the form of the Lord. Why then were you not afraid to speak against my servant Moses?” (8). He departed from the trio, still angry (9). Does the Lord defend His leaders today? Isn’t that clear from the passages outlining their function as leaders and overseers (Acts 20:28; 1 Th. 5:12-13; Heb. 13:7,17). We should think twice, then think again, about idle criticisms against God’s leaders (1 Tim. 5:19).
The Lord responds to unjust criticism (10-16). Many Bible readers wonder why only Miriam is struck with leprosy. There is a linguistic reason. “The section begins with the feminine singular form of the verb watĕdabber, implicating Miriam as the leader in this endeavor” (Cole, NAC, 200). But Aaron fears retribution, too (11). Moses’ compassion is immediately apparent, as he cries out to God for her (13). I appreciate how the ESV shows the depth of Moses’ concern: “O God, please heal her—please” (13). What a beautiful example for leadership today, even if maligned by a critic, to intercede for them in their trouble. God shows no tolerance for petty jealousy and idle criticism. Miriam has to bear the consequences of her complaining. Divine disdain for grumbling is such that, even in the senior leadership circle, He strikes Miriam with leprosy. He immediately heals her, but she has to be the shame and ostracism of her sin for an entire week (14-15). It was a painful lesson for her, and it should have been a graphic illustration for the whole nation.
Criticism is engrained in human tendency. Oftentimes, pettiness drives it. When we do not rule over our spirit, it can lead us to trouble. Yet, God seems especially protective of those whom He sets in positions of leadership. He even wants us praying for our secular leaders (1 Tim. 2:2). Though it cuts against the grain of the culture, whose contempt for leadership declines continually, we should uphold and respect the men who shepherd the church of His Son.


